The European Commission submitted to the EFSA Panel on Plant Health a Dossier by USDA proposing a systems approach to mitigate the risk of entry of Bretziella fagacearum to the EU when trading oak logs with bark from the USA. Due to the forthcoming ban of methyl bromide (MB), the Dossier indicates sulfuryl fluoride (SF) as the substitute fumigant for this commodity. After collecting additional evidence from USDA,EU NPPOs, external experts and the published literature, the Panel performed a quantitative assessment on the likelihood of pest freedom for B. fagacearum at the point of entry in the EU, comparing the proposed systems approach with those already implemented by Commission Decision 2005/359/EC. The Panel provided also a non-quantitative assessment for all risk reduction options (RROs) proposed to be undertaken in the EU, from the point of entry to processing at the sawmill. The quantitative assessment until the EU point of entry, based on experts’ judgement, indicated that: i) the most effective import option remains the current one with MB (95% certainty that between 9,573 and 10,000 containers per 10,000 would be free of B. fagacearum), followed by that with SF (95% certainty that between 8,639 and 10,000 containers per 10,000 would be free of B. fagacearum) and, last, by the other existing option based on delivering white oak logs in certain periods of the year to certain regions of the EU without fumigation (95% certainty, between 7,803 and 10,000 containers per 10,000). RROs proposed to be undertaken in the EU are expected to further reduce the risk of establishment of B. fagacearum, should these RROs be regulated, correctly implemented and checked by NPPOs. A wood pathway analysis is needed to quantitatively assess the importance of each measure and to optimise regulatory actions and risk management efforts.
Keywords: Quercus spp.; fumigant treatment; fungi; nitidulid beetle; pathway analysis; veneer wood.
*Full text article online at https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.2903/j.efsa.2020.6352
Armstrong JW, Brash D and Waddell BC, 2014. Comprehensive literature review of fumigants and disinfestation strategies, methods and techniques pertinent to potential use as quarantine treatments for New Zealand export logs. Plant & Food Research SPTS No. 10678, Plant & Food Research, Palmerston North, New Zealand.
Barak AV, Wang Y, Xu L, Rong Z, Hang X and Zhan G, 2005. Methyl bromide as a quarantine treatment for Anoplophora glabripennis (Coleoptera: Cerambycidae) in regulated wood packing material. Journal of Economic Entomology, 98, 1911–1916.
Barak AV, Wang Y, Zhan G, Wu Y, Xu L, and Huang Q, 2006. Sulfuryl fluoride as a quarantine treatment for Anoplophora glabripennis (Coleoptera: Cerambycidae) in regulated wood packing material. Journal of Economic Entomology, 99, 1628–1635.
Barak AV, Messenger M, Neese P, Thoms E and Fraser I, 2010. Sulfuryl fluoride treatment as a quarantine treatment for emerald ash borer (Coleoptera: Buprestidae) in ash logs. Journal of Economic Entomology, 103, 603–611.
Bonifácio LF, Sousa E, Naves P, Inácio ML, Henriques J, Mota M et al., 2014. Efficacy of sulfuryl fluoride against the pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus (Nematoda: Aphelenchidae), in Pinus pinaster boards. Pest Management Science 70, 6–13.
Cartwright JB, Edwards DW and McMullen MJ, 1953. Sterilization of timber with methyl bromide. Nature, 172, 552–553.
Dwinell LD, Thoms E and Prabhakaran S, 2003. Effect of sulfuryl fluoride on the pinewood nematode in pine wood. In: Annual International Research Conference on Methyl Bromide Alternatives and Emissions Reductions, November 3–6, San Diego, California, pp. 1–4.
Hall M, Najar?Rodriguez A, Adlam A, Hall A and Brash D, 2017. Sorption and desorption characteristics of methyl bromide during and after fumigation of pine (Pinus radiata D. Don) logs. Pest Management Science, 73, 874–879.
Kenaga EE, 1957. Some biological, chemical and physical properties of sulfuryl fluoride as an insecticidal fumigant. Journal of Economic Entomology, 50, 1–6.
Juzwik J, Yang A, Chen Z, White MS, Shugrue S and Mack R, 2019. Vacuum steam treatment eradicates viable Bretziella fagacearum from logs cut from wilted Quercus rubra. Plant Dis. 103, 276–283. https://doi.org/10.1094/pdis-07-18-1252-re
Juzwik J, Yang A, Myers S, Furtado M and Taylor A, 2017. Survival of Ceratocystis fagacearum following red oak log fumigation with sulfuryl fluoride Proceedings of the Annual Meeting the American Phytopathological Society (APS). Phytopathology, 107, 45 pp.
Liese W and Ruetze M, 1985. Development of a fumigation treatment of oak logs against Ceratocystis fagacearum. EPPO Bulletin, 15, 29–36.
Liese W, Knigge H and Ruetze M, 1981. Fumigation experiments with methyl?bromide on oak wood. Material und Organismen, 16, 265–280.
Macdonald WL, Schmidt EL and Harner EJ, 1985. Methyl?bromide eradication of the oak wilt fungus from red and white oak logs. Forest Products Journal, 35, 11?1611?1.
Mizobuchi M, Matsuoka I, Soma Y, Kishino H, Yabuta S, Imamura M, Mizuno T, Hirose Y and Kawakami F, 1996. Susceptibility of forest insect pests to sulfuryl fluoride. 2. Ambrosia beetles. Research Bulletin of the Plant Protection Service Japan, 32, 77–82.
Najar?Rodriguez AJ, Hall MKD, Adlam AR, Hall AJ, Burgess SB, Somerfield KG, Page BBC and Brash DW, 2015. Developing new fumigation schedules for the phytosanitary treatment of New Zealand export logs: comparative toxicity of two fumigants to the burnt pine longhorn beetle, Arhopalus ferus. New Zealand Plant Protection, 68, 19–25.
Osbrink WLA, Scheffrahn RH, Su N?Y and Rust MK, 1987. Laboratory comparisons of sulfuryl fluoride toxicity and mean time of mortality among ten termite species (Isoptera: Hodotermitidae, Kalotermitidae, Rhinotermitidae). Journal of Economic Entomology, 80, 1044–1047.
Parameswaran N and Ruetze M, 1984. Effect of methyl bromide fumigation on the ultrastructure of Ceratocystis fagacearum (Bretz) Hunt. Material und Organismen, 19, 133–140.
Ren YL, Lee BH and Padovan B, 2011. Penetration of methyl bromide, sulfuryl fluoride, ethanedinitrile and phosphine into timber blocks and the sorption rate of the fumigants. Journal of Stored Products Research, 47, 63–68.
Ruetze M and Liese W, 1985. A postfumigation test (TTC) for oak logs. Holzforschung, 39, 327–330. https://doi.org/10.1515/hfsg.19220.127.116.117
Scheffrahn RH and Thoms EM, 1993. Penetration of sulfuryl fluoride and methyl bromide through selected substrates during fumigation. Down to Earth, 48, 15–19.
Schmidt EL, 1982. Methyl bromide eradication of the oak wilt fungus from lumber. International Journal of Wood Preservation, 2, 123–126.
Schmidt EL, 1983. Minimum temperature for methyl?bromide eradication of Ceratocystis?fagacearum in red oak log pieces. Plant Disease, 67, 1338–1339.
Schmidt EL, 1985. Control of mold and stain on methyl?bromide fumigated red oak sapwood. Forest Products Journal, 35, 61–62.
Schmidt EL and Christopherson ER, 1997. Effects of fumigants on parenchyma viability in red oak log sections. Forest Products Journal, 47, 61–63.
Schmidt EL and Kreber B, 1998. Effects of two fumigants and a fungicide formulation on the development of kiln brown stain in radiata pine lumber. Holz als Roh ? und Werkstoff, 56, 416?420.
Schmidt EL, Macdonald WL, Rutze MM et al., 1982. Methyl?bromide eradication of the oak wilt fungus in logs and lumber. Phytopathology, 72, 979.
Schmidt EL, Ruetze MM and French DW, 1982. Methyl bromide treatment of oak wilt infected logs: Laboratory and preliminary field fumigations. Forest Products Journal, 32, 46?49.
Schmidt E, Juzwik J and Schneider B, 1997. Sulfuryl fluoride fumigation of red oak logs eradicates the oak wilt fungus. Holz Als Roh?Und Werkstoff, 55, 315—318.
Schmidt EL, Cassens DL and Jordan BA, 2001a. Control of graystain in yellow?poplar lumber by log fumigation with sulfuryl fluoride. Forest Products Journal, 51, 50–52.
Schmidt EL, Kreber B and Boon S, 2001b. Fumigation of red beech logs for reducing gray stain in lumber. Forest Products Journal, 51, 89–91.
Schortemeyer M, Thomas K, Haack RA, Uzunovic A, Hoover K, Simpson JA and Grgurinovic CA, 2011. Appropriateness of probit?9 in the development of quarantine treatments for timber and timber commodities. Journal of Economic Entomology, 104, 717–731.
Seabright KW, Davila?Flores A, Myers SW and Taylor A, 2020. Efficacy of methyl bromide and alternative fumigants against pinewood nematode in pine wood samples. Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection, 127, 393–400.
Simpson WT, 2001. Chapter 10 – Log and lumber storage. USDA Agricultural Handbook AH?188: Dry Kiln Operator’s Manual, 220–238.
Soma Y, Yabuta S, Mizoguti M, Kishino H, Matsuoka I, Goto M, Akagawa T, Ikeda T and Kawakami F, 1996. Susceptibility of forest insect pests to sulfuryl fluoride. 1. Wood borers and bark beetles. Research Bulletin of the Plant Protection Service Japan, 32, 69–76.
Soma Y, Mizobuchi M, Oogita T, Misumi T, Kishono H, Akagawa T and Kawakami F, 1997. Susceptibility of forest insect pests to sulfuryl fluoride. 3. Susceptibility to sulfuryl fluoride at 25°C. Research Bulletin of the Plant Protection Service Japan, 33, 25–30.
Soma Y, Naito H, Misumi T, Mizobuchi M, Tsuchiya Y, Matsuoka I, Kawakami F, Hirata K and Komatsu H, 2001. Effects of some fumigants on pine wood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, infecting wooden packages. Susceptibility of pine wood nematode to methyl bromide, sulfuryl fluoride and methyl isothiocyanate. Research Bulletin of the Plant Protection Service Japan, 37, 19–26.
Sprenkel RJ and Williams LH, 1988. Ovicidal activity of Vikane gas fumigant on anobiid and lyctid beetle eggs. Down to Earth, 44, 15–19.
Stewart D, 1957. Sulfuryl fluoride?a new fumigant for control of the drywood termite Kalotermes minor (Hagen). Journal of Economic Entomology, 50, 7–11.
Su N?Y and Scheffrahn RH, 1986. Field comparison of sulfuryl fluoride susceptibility among three termite species (Isoptera: Kalotermitidae, Rhinotermitidae) during structural fumigation. Journal of Economic Entomology, 79, 903–908.
Su N?Y and Scheffrahn RH, 1990. Efficacy of sulfuryl fluoride against four beetle pests of museums (Coleoptera: Dermestidae, Anobiidae). Journal of Economic Entomology, 83, 879–882.
Su N?Y, Osbrink WLA and Scheffrahn RH, 1989. Concentration?time relationship for fumigant efficacy of sulfuryl fluoride against the Formosan subterranean termite (Isoptera: Rhinotermitidae). Journal of Economic Entomology, 82, 156–158.
Thoms EM and Scheffrahn RH, 1994. Control of pests by fumigation with Vikane gas fumigant (sulfuryl fluoride). Down to Earth, 49, 23–30.
Tubajika KM and Barak AV, 2006. Efficacy of sulfuryl fluoride and methyl bromide against wood?inhabiting fungi. Proceedings of the Annual International Research Conference on Methyl Bromide Alternatives and Emissions Reductions, Orlando, Florida, USA, 6–9 November 2006, 147 pp.
Tubajika KM and Barak AV, 2007. Methyl iodide and sulfuryl fluoride as quarantine treatments for solid wood packing material. Annual International Research Conference on Methyl Bromide Alternatives and Emissions Reductions: [proceedings] 2007, 131 pp.
Tubajika KM and Barak AV, 2011. Fungitoxicity of methyl iodide, sulfuryl fluoride, and methyl bromide to Ceratocystis fagacearum in red oak, maple, poplar, birch and pine wood. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 2, 268–275.
University of Kentucky, 2016. Example Fumigants. In: Fumigation Training Manual. UK Pesticide Safety Education Program. University of Kentucky, College of Agriculture, Departments of Entomology. Cooperative Extension Service. Available online: http://www.uky.edu/Ag/Entomology/PSEP/fumexamples.html
Uzunovic A, Mukherjee A, Elder P and Myers SW, 2017. Rapid screening of sulfuryl fluoride as a potential phytosanitary treatment for a broad selection of fungi relevant to forestry. Forest Products Journal, 67, 4–12.
Williams LH and Sprenkel RJ, 1990. Ovicidal activity of sulfuryl fluoride to anobiid and lyctid beetle eggs of various ages. Journal of Entomological Science, 25, 366–375.
Woodward RP and Schmidt EL, 1995. Fungitoxicity of sulfuryl fluoride to Ceratocystis?fagacearum in?vitro and in wilted red oak log sections. Plant Disease, 79, 1237–1239.
Yang A, Juzwik J, White M, Chen Z, Shugrue S and Mack R, 2017. Vacuum steam as a promising alternative to methyl bromide for killing Ceratocystis fagacearum in Quercus rubra logs for global export. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting the American Phytopathological Society (APS). Phytopathology, 107, 47 pp.
Yang A, Seabright K, Juzwik J, Myers SW and Taylor A, 2019. Survival of the oak wilt fungus in logs fumigated with sulfuryl fluoride and methyl bromide. Forest Products Journal, 69, 87–95.
Yu SY, 2014. The Toxicology and Biochemistry of Insecticides. Publisher CRC Press, 2nd Edition, 348 pp.
Yu D, Barak AV, Jiao Y, Chen Z, Zhang G, Chen Z, Kang L and Yang W, 2010. Sulfuryl fluoride as a quarantine treatment for Chlorophorus annularis (Coleoptera: Cerambycidae) in Chinese bamboo poles. Journal of Economic Entomology, 103, 277–283.
Zhang Z, 2006. Use of sulfuryl fluoride as an alternative fumigant to methyl bromide in export log fumigation. New Zealand Plant Protection, 59, 223–227.
*Full text article online at https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.2903/j.efsa.2020.6352