Fluoride Action Network

Water fluoridation’s fraught history is focus of award-winning article

Source: Univerwity of Hawai | April 9th, 2020 | By Marc Arakaki
Location: United States, Hawaii


frank zelko headshot on backdrop of cup of water

A University of Hawaii at Manoa associate professor of history received an esteemed environmental history national honor.

Frank Zelko was awarded the 2019 Alice Hamilton Prize for best article by the American Society for Environmental History for his piece titled Optimizing nature: Invoking the “natural” in the struggle over water fluoridation in the journal History of Science.

“I was very pleased to hear that I had won the award. It’s always great to be appreciated by one’s academic peers,” Zelko said. “The only disappointment was that, because of the cancelation of the society’s annual conference due to COVID-19, I didn’t have the award presented to me in person. That will have to wait until next year’s meeting in Boston.”

Zelko’s article focused on water fluoridation in the mid-twentieth century and how early proponents portrayed the practice as ‘natural.’ Zelko’s research determined this was a political move and had little to do with science because the substance used in fluoridation is an untreated toxic waste product of fertilizer and aluminum industries. Furthermore, in places where fluoride compounds did occur naturally in water, such as China and India, significant health problems arose. The same toxicologists who signed off on water fluoridation used identical logic in defending the addition of lead to gasoline. Zelko said it was part of the pre-environmental scientific hubris expressed in the slogan ‘better living through chemistry.’

“Dr. Zelko’s project on the history of municipal water fluoridation in the U.S., funded in part by a grant by the National Institutes of Health, shines a light on questions of environmental science, policy and the economy,” UH Manoa Department of History Chair and Associate Professor Shana Brown said. “His research is of great benefit specifically here in Hawaii where the health and sustainability of our water resources must be a top priority.”

“The Alice Hamilton Prize is one that recognizes outstanding scholarship and professional accomplishment. UH and the College of Arts and Humanities are lucky to have a scholar of Professor Zelko’s caliber in the critically vital field of environmental history,” UH Manoa College of Arts and Humanities Dean Peter Arnade said.

*Original article online at https://www.hawaii.edu/news/2020/04/09/water-fluoridation-fraught-history-article/