Fluoride Action Network

Watertown: Six primary council candidates attend forum

Source: Watertown Daily Times | September 6th, 2013 | By Craig Fox, Staff Writer
Location: United States, New York

Fluoride. The so-called roommate law. Blighted neighborhoods. Better communication with residents. Council salaries. Should the city have a dog park?

These were just some of the issues that the six Watertown City Council primary candidates discussed during a forum Thursday night at the Italian American Civic Association club on Bellew Avenue.

Not a debate, the event was billed as a chance for voters to hear and see the candidates running in Tuesday’s primary. It was the only time incumbents Teresa R. Macaluso and Jeffrey M. Smith and challengers Jasmine W. Borreggine, Stephen A. Jennings, Cody J. Horbacz and Rodney J. LaFave came together to discuss their views on issues facing the city.

Attended by about 40 people, the forum did not produce any sparks, with candidates having no chance to respond to their opponents’ answers.

The only news that came out of the event was produced when a panelist asked Ms. Macaluso about her views on whether fluoride should continue to be added to the city’s water system.

It was the first time she said she personally would like the city not to use the tasteless and colorless chemical, but she also added that she would listen to her constituents to see if it they would like to see it remain.

“I know I’m going to be crucified,” she said, adding that children need fluoride to protect their teeth but that its use is not warranted for adults.

Last winter, fluoride became an issue when council members were faced with purchasing new equipment for the program. Within a few weeks, a group of anti-fluoride activists started attending council meetings to urge its elimination from the water supply.

The issue also influenced the entrance of two other candidates — Mr. Jennings, a supporter of fluoridation, and Mrs. Borreggine, who opposes it — into the race. Neither they nor the other three candidates were asked about their views on fluoride Thursday night.

But Mr. Jennings was asked about his proposal to help deteriorating houses and neighborhoods. He was asked whether it was “out of the realm” of the city’s responsibility to be involved in such activities.

“I think it is out of the realm of our current city government,” he answered. “We have to change our thinking.”

Based on a national program, he would like to see city planners, law enforcement officers and educators work collaboratively to clean up neighborhoods and rental properties, helping to improve people’s lives along the way.

But Mr. Smith, who has been on the council for 10 years, said programs like that are the responsibility of county government, not the city.

“City government is not into socialization,” he said, adding that he generally opposes using public money to fix up private rental properties.

Calling herself “a fiscal conservative” with centrist views, Mrs. Borreggine said she is for “limited government and lower taxes.” She believes that government “should not be in your bedroom or your health system.”

… The top four vote-getters in the primary will move on to the general election Nov. 5.

Local radio host Glenn Curry moderated the forum, while the panel consisted of Channel 7’s John Moore, WTNY radio host Nathan Lehman and YNN’s Brian Dwyer.