Okay, let’s set some rules: we’re not talking about water hardness here. We know that’s bad for a lot of people. But it’s something that’s clearly visible. Even if some people feel less affected, nobody’s denying that it can visibly impact lives (and kitchens.) We talked about , but this time we’re narrowing it down to an issue that will remain even after the new reverse-osmosis plant is finished.

The debate that’s risen up over fluoride in Western Springs, however, is a different animal because the very facts are disagreed about. For some, fluoride added to drinking water represents a completely unnecessary and potentially grave health threat imposed by local government. For others, fluoride in the amounts recommend by the American Dental Association represent a critical tooth-decay fighting tool, otherwise completely harmless, and any concerns are based on Internet misinformation and conspiracy theory.

Each side has waved scientific papers to back up their claims; has the Western Springs Board of Trustees. At this point, the issue is on the back burner while the reverse-osmosis plant construction is ongoing. But it’s likely to crop up again when the project nears completion.

This week, we’re taking the pulse from our readers. Adding fluoride as a tooth-decay battle: bad or good? Serious threat or Dr. Strangelove nonsense? Who do you believe? What’s your call?

Please vote and then share your thoughts in the comments!