Abstract

Genotoxic effects observed in vitro, only at high doses or high levels of cytotoxicity, will be false positives if such conditions are not achieved or cannot be tolerated in vivo. However, for such effects to be disregarded there must be a threshold dose or level of cytotoxicity below which genotoxicity is absent. Sodium fluoride (NaF) has previously been shown to be clastogenic in vitro in Syrian hamster cells and human fibroblasts. We have extended these studies in human fibroblasts and included a positive control (mitomycin C, MMC) which is clastogenic in vivo and carcinogenic, and a chemically related control (NaCl). Cytotoxicity was measured as mitotic inhibition and cell death (loss of clonogenicity). The results are used to illustrate the problems associated with quantitative extrapolation from in vitro tests to human risk, as follows. (1) There appears to be a threshold response (clastogenicity vs. dose) with NaF at around 10 micrograms/ml (48 h exposure) but a more definitive conclusion must await elucidation of the mechanisms of clastogenicity. (2) NaCl is weakly clastogenic at 1000 times the threshold dose for NaF. The mechanisms are unlikely to be similar. (3) No clastogenicity was detected with NaF below about 30% mitotic inhibition but the relationship between clastogenicity and mitotic inhibition was similar for NaF and MMC. (4) There was no obvious threshold in the relationship between clastogenicity and cell killing with NaF. MMC was less clastogenic than NaF at equitotoxic doses. Observations 3 and 4 preclude the possibility of regarding the clastogenicity of NaF as a false positive by virtue of associated cytotoxicity.

• Related Studies :

  • Transforming activities of sodium fluoride in cultured Syrian hamster embryo and BALB/3T3 cells

    The transforming activity of sodium fluoride was studied in the SHE and the BALB/3T3 cell culture systems. Initiating and promoting activities were then investigated by means of the orthogonal methodology. Sodium fluoride was found to induce morphological transformation of SHE cells seeded on a feeder layer of X-irradiated cells at

  • Chromosome aberrations in cultured rat bone marrow cells treated with inorganic fluorides

    The genotoxic effects of inorganic fluorides were investigated by treating cultured rat bone marrow cells with varying concentrations (0.1-100 microM) of potassium fluoride (KF) and sodium fluoride (NaF) for different durations (12, 24 and 36 h) and measuring the incidence of cells with aberrations and number of breaks per cell.

  • Chromosomal changes in maize induced by hydrogen fluoride gas

    Maize seedlings of the genotype A1A2C1Wx were fumigated in growth chambers with hydrogen fluoride (HF) at a concentration of about 3 ug/m3. The experiment was run for 10 days, with the first group of treated plants removed from the chambers after 4 days and then at intervals of 2 days.

  • Effects of melatonin and amla antioxidants on fluoride-induced genotoxicity in human peripheral blood lymphocyte cells

    This investigation reports genotoxic effects of sodium fluoride (NaF) at 17, 34, and 51 ?M for 72 hr and induction of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) and related changes, together with ameliorative effects by melatonin and amla, in human peripheral blood lymphocyte cell cultures. The cell cycle proliferative index (CCPI) significantly

  • Health Effects of Ingested Fluoride

    Excerpts: INTRODUCTION Fluoridation of drinking water has been a subject of controversy for decades. Over the past 50 years, the incidence of dental caries (cavities) has declined considerably in the United States, an important health advance that most scientists attribute principally to increased access to fluoridated water and dental products. According to

• Related FAN Content :

  • Fluoride's Mutagenicity: The "Oral Health Research Institute's" Studies

    Although many in vitro and in vivo studies have detected mutagenic effects from fluoride exposure, the Oral Health Research Institute at Indiana University's School of Dentistry has repeatedly failed to find any such effect in multiple studies on the subject.

  • Fluoride & Liver Cancers in NTP Bioassay

    On October 28, 1988, Battelle Columbus Laboratories submitted its Final Report to the NTP concerning the results of the Mouse study. The principal finding of Battelle's report was that a dose-dependent increase of a rare liver cancer (hepatocholangiocarcinoma) had occurred in the fluoride-treated male and female mice.

  • Fluoride & Osteosarcoma: A Timeline

    Several human epidemiological studies have found an association between fluoride in drinking water and the occurrence of osteosarcoma (bone cancer) in young males. These studies are consistent with the National Toxicology Program's (NTP) cancer bioassay which found that fluoride-treated male rats had an dose-dependent increase in osteosarcoma. Although a number of studies have failed to detect an association between fluoride and osteosarcoma, none of these studies have measured the risk of fluoride at specific windows in time, which based on recent results, is the critical question with respect to fluoride and osteosarcoma.

  • NTP Bioassay on Fluoride/Cancer (1990)

    In 1977, the U.S. Congress requested that animal studies be conducted to determine if fluoride can cause cancer. The result of the Congressional request was an extensive animal study conducted in the 1980s by the National Toxicology Program (NTP) and published in 1990. The main finding of NTP's study was a dose-dependent increase in osteosarcoma (bone cancer) among the fluoride-treated male rats. 

  • A Critique of Gelberg's Study on Fluoride/Osteosarcoma in New York

    The case-control study by Gelberg, published first as a PhD dissertation and then later in two peer-reviewed journals, may represent the most substantive study on fluoride/osteosarcoma previous to Bassin’s 2001 analysis. In assessing Gelberg’s data, we were at first struck by the existence of several notable errors in both the thesis and papers. While these errors do raise questions about the study, our primary concern with Gelberg’s work relates to the methods she used to analyze her data.