Abstract

Background

Although the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) considers fluoridation of community water systems (CWSs) to be a major public health achievement responsible for reducing dental disease, recent epidemiologic evidence suggests that chronic exposure to population-relevant levels of fluoride may also be associated with adverse child neurodevelopmental outcomes. To our knowledge, a nationally representative database of CWS fluoride concentration estimates that can be readily linked to US epidemiologic cohorts for further study is not publicly available. Our objectives were to evaluate broad regional and sociodemographic inequalities in CWS fluoride concentrations across the US, and to determine if county-level racial/ethnic composition was associated with county-level CWS fluoride.

Methods

We generated CWS-level (N?=?32,495) and population weighted county-level (N?=?2152) fluoride concentration estimates using over 250,000 routine compliance monitoring records collected from the US Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Third Six Year Review (2006-2011). We compared CWS-level fluoride distributions across subgroups including region, population size served, and county sociodemographic characteristics. In county-level spatial error models, we also evaluated geometric mean ratios (GMRs) of CWS fluoride per 10% higher proportion of residents belonging to a given racial/ethnic subgroup.

Results

4.5% of CWSs (serving >2.9 million residents) reported mean 2006-2011 fluoride concentrations ?1500?µg/L (the World Health Organization’s guideline for drinking water quality). Arithmetic mean, 90^th, and 95^th percentile contaminant concentrations were greatest in CWSs reliant on groundwater, located in the Southwest and Eastern Midwest, and serving Semi-Urban, Hispanic communities. In fully adjusted spatial error models, the GMR (95% CI) of CWS fluoride per a 10% higher proportion of county residents that were Hispanic/Latino was 1.16 (1.10, 1.23).

Impact statement

We find that over 2.9 million US residents are served by public water systems with average fluoride concentrations exceeding the World Health Organization’s guidance limit. We also find significant inequalities in community water system fluoride concentration estimates (2006-2011) across the US, especially for Hispanic/Latino communities who also experience elevated arsenic and uranium in regulated public drinking water systems. Our fluoride estimates can be leveraged in future epidemiologic studies to assess the potential association between chronic fluoride exposure and related adverse outcomes.

Available online at https://www.nature.com/articles/s41370-023-00570-w

Excerpt:

References 

Articles referenced by this article (26)

• Water fluoridation for the prevention of dental caries.

  Iheozor-Ejiofor Z, Worthington HV, Walsh T, O’Malley L, Clarkson JE, Macey R, Alam R, Tugwell P, Welch V, Glenny AM

  Cochrane Database Syst Rev, (6):CD010856 2015

  MED: 26092033

  ---

• The effectiveness of community water fluoridation in the United States.

  Horowitz HS

  J Public Health Dent, (5 Spec No):253-258 1996

  MED: 9034970

  ---

• School fluoridation studies in Elk Lake, Pennsylvania, and Pike County, Kentucky–results after eight years.

  Horowitz HS, Heifetz SB, Law FE, Driscoll WS

  Am J Public Health Nations Health, (12):2240-2250 1968

  MED: 4387263

  ---

• Prenatal fluoride exposure and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms in children at 6-12?years of age in Mexico City.

  Bashash M, Marchand M, Hu H, Till C, Martinez-Mier EA, Sanchez BN, Basu N, Peterson KE, Green R, Schnaas L, Mercado-Garcia A, Hernandez-Avila M, Tellez-Rojo MM

  Environ Int, (Pt 1):658-666 2018

  MED: 30316181

  ---

• Prenatal Fluoride Exposure and Cognitive Outcomes in Children at 4 and 6-12 Years of Age in Mexico.

  Bashash M, Thomas D, Hu H, Martinez-Mier EA, Sanchez BN, Basu N, Peterson KE, Ettinger AS, Wright R, Zhang Z, Liu Y, Schnaas L, Mercado-Garcia A, Tellez-Rojo MM, Hernandez-Avila M

  Environ Health Perspect, (9):097017 2017

  MED: 28937959

  ---

• The relationships between low levels of urine fluoride on children’s intelligence, dental fluorosis in endemic fluorosis areas in Hulunbuir, Inner Mongolia, China.

  Ding Y, YanhuiGao , Sun H, Han H, Wang W, Ji X, Liu X, Sun D

  J Hazard Mater, (2-3):1942-1946 2010

  MED: 21237562

  ---

• Association Between Maternal Fluoride Exposure During Pregnancy and IQ Scores in Offspring in Canada.

  Green R, Lanphear B, Hornung R, Flora D, Martinez-Mier EA, Neufeld R, Ayotte P, Muckle G, Till C

  JAMA Pediatr, (10):940-948 2019

  MED: 31424532

  ---

• Critical windows of fluoride neurotoxicity in Canadian children.

  Farmus L, Till C, Green R, Hornung R, Martinez Mier EA, Ayotte P, Muckle G, Lanphear BP, Flora DB

  Environ Res, 111315 2021

  MED: 34051202

  ---

• Developmental fluoride neurotoxicity: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

  Choi AL, Sun G, Zhang Y, Grandjean P

  Environ Health Perspect, (10):1362-1368 2012

  MED: 22820538

  ---

• Maternal fluoride exposure, fertility and birth outcomes: The MIREC cohort.

  Goodman C, Hall M, Green R, Hornung R, Martinez-Mier EA, Lanphear B, Till C

  Environ Adv, 100135 2021

  MED: 36644332

  ---

• Maternal and fetal exposures to fluoride during mid-gestation among pregnant women in northern California.

  Abduweli Uyghurturk D, Goin DE, Martinez-Mier EA, Woodruff TJ, DenBesten PK

  Environ Health, (1):38 2020

  MED: 32248806

  ---

• Developmental fluoride neurotoxicity: an updated review.

  Grandjean P

  Environ Health, (1):110 2019

  MED: 31856837

  ---

• Environmental justice and drinking water quality: are there socioeconomic disparities in nitrate levels in U.S. drinking water?

  Schaider LA, Swetschinski L, Campbell C, Rudel RA

  Environ Health, (1):3 2019

  MED: 30651108

  ---

• Sociodemographic inequalities in uranium and other metals in community water systems across the USA, 2006-11: a cross-sectional study.

  Ravalli F, Yu Y, Bostick BC, Chillrud SN, Schilling K, Basu A, Navas-Acien A, Nigra AE

  Lancet Planet Health, (4):e320-e330 2022

  MED: 35397220

  ---

• Inequalities in Public Water Arsenic Concentrations in Counties and Community Water Systems across the United States, 2006-2011.

  Nigra AE, Chen Q, Chillrud SN, Wang L, Harvey D, Mailloux B, Factor-Litvak P, Navas-Acien A

  Environ Health Perspect, (12):127001 2020

  MED: 33295795

  ---

• Nationwide geospatial analysis of county racial and ethnic composition and public drinking water arsenic and uranium.

  Martinez-Morata I, Bostick BC, Conroy-Ben O, Duncan DT, Jones MR, Spaur M, Patterson KP, Prins SJ, Navas-Acien A, Nigra AE

  Nat Commun, (1):7461 2022

  MED: 36460659

  ---

• Comparison of US County-Level Public Health Performance Rankings With County Cluster and National Rankings: Assessment Based on Prevalence Rates of Smoking and Obesity and Motor Vehicle Crash Death Rates.

  Wallace M, Sharfstein JM, Kaminsky J, Lessler J

  JAMA Netw Open, (1):e186816 2019

  MED: 30646196

  ---

• Estimating the High-Arsenic Domestic-Well Population in the Conterminous United States.

  Ayotte JD, Medalie L, Qi SL, Backer LC, Nolan BT

  Environ Sci Technol, (21):12443-12454 2017

  MED: 29043784

  ---

• The County Health Rankings: rationale and methods.

  Remington PL, Catlin BB, Gennuso KP

  Popul Health Metr, 11 2015

  MED: 25931988

  ---

• Associations between private well water and community water supply arsenic concentrations in the conterminous United States.

  Spaur M, Lombard MA, Ayotte JD, Harvey DE, Bostick BC, Chillrud SN, Navas-Acien A, Nigra AE

  Sci Total Environ, 147555 2021

  MED: 33991916

  ---

• Beyond the Mean: Quantile Regression to Explore the Association of Air Pollution with Gene-Specific Methylation in the Normative Aging Study.

  Bind MA, Coull BA, Peters A, Baccarelli AA, Tarantini L, Cantone L, Vokonas PS, Koutrakis P, Schwartz JD

  Environ Health Perspect, (8):759-765 2015

  MED: 25769179

  ---

• The drinking water disparities framework: on the origins and persistence of inequities in exposure.

  Balazs CL, Ray I

  Am J Public Health, (4):603-611 2014

  MED: 24524500

  ---

• Fluoride occurrence in United States groundwater.

  McMahon PB, Brown CJ, Johnson TD, Belitz K, Lindsey BD

  Sci Total Environ, 139217 2020

  MED: 32438175

  ---

• Fluoride exposure and kidney and liver function among adolescents in the United States: NHANES, 2013-2016.

  Malin AJ, Lesseur C, Busgang SA, Curtin P, Wright RO, Sanders AP

  Environ Int, 105012 2019

  MED: 31402058

  ---

• Associations of renal function with urinary excretion of metals: Evidence from NHANES 2003-2012.

  Jin R, Zhu X, Shrubsole MJ, Yu C, Xia Z, Dai Q

  Environ Int, (Pt 2):1355-1362 2018

  MED: 30442456

  ---

• Association Between Water Fluoridation and Income-Related Dental Caries of US Children and Adolescents.

  Sanders AE, Grider WB, Maas WR, Curiel JA, Slade GD

  JAMA Pediatr, (3):288-290 2019

  MED: 30688985

  ---

Funding 

---

Funders who supported this work.

NIEHS NIH HHS (2)

• Grant ID: P42 ES033719

  26 publications

• Grant ID: P30 ES009089

  1399 publications

Print PDF

• Related Studies :

  • Relation Between Intelligence and COMT Gene Polymorphism in Children Aged 8-12 in the Endemic Fluorosis Area and Non-Endemic Fluorosis Area.

    1.1 Subjects According to the principle that a selected population lives in a similar natural environment and has similar lifestyle and diet habits, one township in the endemic fluorosis area and one township in the non-endemic fluorosis area in a certain region were respectively selected as sites for population sampling. In

  • Neurotransmitter and receptor changes in the brains of fetuses from areas of endemic fluorosis.

    The levels of neurotransmitters and receptors in brain tissue of aborted fetuses from areas of endemic fluorosis were tested. The results showed that in 10 fetuses from a high fluoride area ranging in age from 5 to 7 months, the levels of norepinephrine, 5-hydroxytryptamine, and a1-receptor were lower, and the level of epinephrine was higher as compared with levels

  • Effects of endemic fluoride poisoning on the intellectual development of children in Baotou.

    Our goal was to investigate the effects of endemic fluoride poisoning on the intellectual development of children living in Baotou, Inner Mongolia. Our method was to select random child subjects from endemic fluoride areas in Baotou and use the illustrated version of the Chinese Standardized Raven Test for use with

  • International differences in the recognition of non-skeletal fluorosis: a comparison of India and New Zealand.

    In India, there has been a change from the situation present in the 1930s–1970s, when fluoride toxicity was seen to involve just the hard tissues of teeth and bones, to the situation in the 2000s–2010s when recognition was given to the occurrence of non-skeletal symptoms and that these were a

  • Intelligence quotient of 7 to 9 year-old children from an area with high fluoride in drinking water.

    This paper reports the effect of chronic high fluoride exposure on children's intelligence quotient (IQ). In this cross sectional study, two urban communities with similar socio-economic and cultural status but with different levels of fluoride in drinking water, in Kerman province of Iran were studied: Koohbanan City (fluoride 2.38 mg/L),

• Related FAN Content :

  • Fluoride: Developmental Neurotoxicity.

    Developmental Neurotoxicity There has been a tremendous amount of research done on the association of exposure to fluoride with developmental neurotoxicity. There are 78 studies reporting reduced IQ (75 studies with children and 3 studies with adults) and several on the impaired learning/memory in animals. And there are studies which link

  • Fluoride's Effect on Fetal Brain

    The human placenta does not prevent the passage of fluoride from a pregnant mother's bloodstream to the fetus. As a result, a fetus can be harmed by fluoride ingested pregnancy. Based on research from China, the fetal brain is one of the organs susceptible to fluoride poisoning. As highlighted by the excerpts

  • Fluoride Affects Learning & Memory in Animals

    An association between elevated fluoride exposure and reduced intelligence has now been observed in 65 IQ studies. Although a link between fluoride and intelligence might initially seem surprising or random, it is actually consistent with a large body of animal research. This animal research includes the following 45 studies (out

  • Fluoride & IQ: 76 Studies

    Note: See the Updated list of fluoride IQ studies at https://fluoridealert.org/researchers/fluoride-iq-studies/the-fluoride-iq-studies/ • As of July 18, 2022, a total of 85 human studies have investigated the relationship between fluoride and human intelligence. • Of these investigations, 76 studies have reported that elevated fluoride exposure is associated with reduced IQ in humans. • The studies

  • Fluoride's Direct Effects on Brain: Animal Studies

    The possibility that fluoride ingestion may impair intelligence and other indices of neurological function is supported by a vast body of animal research, including over 40 studies that have investigated fluoride's effects on brain quality in animals. As discussed by the National Research Council, the studies have consistently demonstrated that fluoride, at widely varying concentrations, is toxic to the brain.