Abstract
Environmental (and occupational) exposure to neurotoxic substances is a worldwide problem that can affect children’s neurodevelopment (ND). In Latin American and Caribbean (LAC) countries there are over 300 million children living under the threat of neurodevelopmental delays due to toxic environmental exposure. Large industrial centers, intense mining and agricultural activities, along with changing complex ecosystems constitute a mosaic that drives contamination of air, water and the food chain. Neurotoxic contaminants such as pesticides (organochlorines, organophosphates, carbamates, pyrethroids, neonicotinoids, and manganese fungicides), chemicals of industrial use (phthalates), and metals (Hg, Pb, Al, As, F, Cd, Mo, Mn) are at the center of environmental exposure studies. Exposure to neurotoxic substances singly or in combination with other compounds or socioeconomic stressors (maternal education, socio-economic and nutritional status) intertwined with occupational and para-occupational exposure can affect ND (motor, cognition, behavior) of children. Significant negative effects of pesticides and neurotoxic elements on ND were found in all studied countries, affecting especially the less-privileged children from laboring families. Studies showed that exposures to the neurotoxicants in human milk are secondary to their more lasting effects during prenatal exposure. This review integrates exposure (prenatal and breastfeeding), metabolism, and ND effects of neurotoxicants. It highlights the overwhelming evidence showing that current levels of exposures are hazardous and detrimental to children’s ND in LAC countries. The evidence indicates that a reduction in neurotoxicant exposure is essential to protect children’s ND. Therefore, it is urgent to adopt policies and actions that prevent and remediate region-specific children’s ND issues.
Excerpt:
Introduction
Environmental neurotoxicants are pollutants that can negatively affect many cellular metabolic-processes through different pathways: neuroendocrine/thyroid hormone disruption (Pb, methyl-Hg, organochlorines, and polychlorinated biphenyls-PCB), oxidative stress (Pb, methyl-Hg, organochlorines, and chlorpyrifos), dopamine dysfunction (Pb, methyl-Hg, As, chlorpyrifos, pyrethroids, and organochlorines) (Heyer and Meredith, 2017; Rock and Patisaul, 2018). Pistollato et al. (2020) studied neurotoxic substances (associated with cognitive deficits – learning and memory impairment in children) of different chemical classes: metals (Pb and methylmercury), pesticides (chlorpyrifos), industrial pollutants (bisphenol A and PCB138), and drugs (valproic acid). Chemicals with a ‘similar’ mode of action (on synaptogenesis, neurite outgrowth, and brain-derived neurotrophic factor) were evaluated by immunocytochemistry and high content imaging analysis. They showed (through in vitro and in silico models) that non-cytotoxic, very low toxic, or moderately toxic concentrations induce developmental neurotoxic effects in mixtures (Pistollato et al., 2020). However, extrapolation of experimental studies to interpret epidemiological data needs caution. Tsatsakis et al. (2019) reported that a cocktail of 13 chemicals at very low doses showed dose-dependent stimulation, rather than inhibition of the nervous system.
Depending on their metabolism and dose, there can be short-term or persistent neurotoxicants, both with long-term health consequences beyond their acute effects. Children are especially vulnerable to neurotoxic exposures that occur during pregnancy and after birth because they respond differently from adults. Most of the exposures in the more sensitive stages of neurodevelopment (ND) occur through maternal environmental exposure during pregnancy and lactation. Therefore, monitoring maternal exposure to environmental neurotoxic substances represents the best surrogate for the unborn and the breastfeeding child.
Environmental neurotoxic chemicals can pose a risk to the neurodevelopment (ND) of children during critical periods of early life, which depend on acquisition, metabolism, and storage during pregnancy and lactation. Half-life of neurotoxic substances in the maternal organism can last from days to years (LaKind et al., 2019). Due to short half-life, pesticides like organophosphate (OP) are rapidly metabolized and eliminated in urine (Barr and Angerer, 2006). Most neurotoxic substances can be characterized as persistent, bioaccumulative chemicals. Therefore, such neurotoxicants (NTs) can pose a neurodevelopmental risk long before conception. Nevertheless, it is important to realize that persistent pollutants (organic or inorganic com,pounds) can occur simultaneously with other NTs that may have a shorter half-life.
Due to contamination of fruits and vegetables with pesticides/residues, most exposure in urban populations occurs continuously through food consumption, but in rural settings, contamination can occur due to occupational and para-occupational exposures. Hertz-Picciotto et al. (2018) estimated the use of OP as 13,404 tonnes for 6 South American countries and 4342 tons for 11 Caribbean and Central American countries. Indeed, measuring passive air sampling in the proximity of schools in Costa Rica, Córdoba Gamboa et al., 2020 detected 10 different pesticides (insecticides, nematicides, fungicides) in more than half of samples. Forde et al. (2015) reported comparatively high urine concentrations of pesticides in Caribbean countries. However, there are other settings that may favor exposure to specific neurotoxicants.
In South American countries (Brazil, Venezuela, Ecuador, Perú, French Guyana) Hg is largely used in artisanal small-scale gold mining (Kristensen et al., 2014); this activity fluctuates with the world price of gold (Branco et al., 2017). To a lesser extent, Hg is used in ritualistic “Santerias” (sprinkling Hg or burning it in a candle to obtain the favor of divinities), or, as a skin-lightning product in soaps and detergents (Masur, 2011). Contamination by Pb can occur from urban environmental pollution (Calderón-Garcidueñas et al., 2013) and cottage ceramic-industry (Counter et al., 2000), and from mining settings along with other neurotoxic metals.
Yáñez et al. (2002) raised crucial questions regarding health assessments and the types of chemical mixtures afflicting developing countries, vicinity of smelters, mines, waste disposal sites, agricultural areas, and at home. Abreu-Villaça and Levin (2017) reviewed exposure to insecticides (organochlorines, organophosphates, pyrethroids, carbamates and neonicotinoids) and off-target ND effects on humans. Comprehensive reviews assessing ND outcomes can be found elsewhere dealing with exposures to environmental substances, like insecticides (Burns et al., 2013) and metal mixtures (Dórea, 2019a, 2019b).
In addition to direct exposure to neurotoxicants, it is recognized that socioeconomic and nutrition-dependent factors can modulate neurodevelopment. Wehby and McCarthy (2013) studied wealth gradients in child neurodevelopment in four Latin American countries (Argentina; Brazil; Chile; Ecuador) and found this relationship to be country-specific; it varied with population demographics, health, and socioeconomic characteristics. They noticed a great disparity in the years of school attendance by mothers; the percentage of Brazilian mothers not having attended secondary school was higher (46%) than mothers from Chile (31%), Argentina (25%), and Ecuador (16%) (Wehby and McCarthy, 2013). Indeed, childhood socioeconomic disadvantage measured as rural living, poor childhood health, illiteracy, farmer occupation, and insufficient income were associated with elderly cognitive impairment in seven LAC cities (Nguyen et al., 2008).
Recently, Malin et al. (2018) showed that both good prenatal and childhood nutrition models contribute to more favorable neurodevelopment (Malin et al., 2018). They also showed that poor nutrition indices could lead to poorer ND (Malin et al., 2018). Indeed, in the Brazilian Amazon, poverty, lack of health infrastructure, and isolation are of concern in children’s cognitive development (Fonseca et al., 2007). Nevertheless, in urban areas, delayed cognitive assessment was significantly associated with stunting (Paine et al., 1992). In other Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) countries, stunting has been significantly associated with psychomotor development (Lasky et al., 1981) and fine motor skills (Cravioto et al., 1966) in Guatemalan children, and altered behavior in Mexican children (Fernald and Grantham-McGregor, 1998). Additionally, living at high altitudes in South American countries is an increased risk factor for neurodevelopment of younger (Wehby, 2013) and older children (Hogan et al., 2010). In the complex scenarios of LAC countries, there are a myriad of environmental interactions with neurotoxicants that could counteract, add or attenuate ND effects. Indeed, Flores-Ramírez et al. (2016) reported that in rural impoverished Mexico there are high percentages (28–49%) of children with chronic malnutrition carrying an additional burden of detectable levels of four or more neurotoxicants. Children (70–82%) in these communities are exposed to NT metals (Mn, Pb, As, and F) and persistent pollutants (dichlorophenyldichloroethylene-DDE, hexachlorobenzene-HCB) (Flores-Ramírez et al., 2016).
The estimate of the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) for the first decade of this century was that 100,000 children (<5 years of age) in the LAC, would die each year from hazards related to the physical, chemical, and biological environment (Laborde et al., 2015). The authors called attention to environmental threats to the health of over 300 million children living in the LAC region. In addition to “traditional hazards of indoor air pollution and contaminated drinking water”, there are exposures to “urban air pollution, toxic synthetic chemicals, pesticides, heavy metals, unsustainable urban growth, hazardous wastes including electrical and electronic waste (e-waste)” (Laborde et al., 2015).
The objective of this review is to integrate studies on overarching neurodevelopmental issues associated with environmental neurotoxicants in the LAC countries, putting into perspective environmental contaminants (neurotoxic metals, pesticides and metabolites), time (pre- and postnatal) and mode of exposure.
Section snippets
Exposure to neurotoxic substances
Environmental neurotoxic substances can co-occur randomly such are the cases of combinations with the most-studied metals, Hg and Pb (Dórea, 2019a, Dórea, 2019b). However, overall, long and short elimination half-life compounds raise important issues of comparative toxicology. Biomarkers of exposure assessment for Pb and DDE (with elimination half-life of years) may not be comparable to OP metabolites with half-life elimination of hours. While insecticides can be quantified in biological
Neurotoxic contaminants in milk
Concentrations of chemicals in breast milk and blood of mothers and babies are indicators of both current and prenatal exposures, and are used to assess risk and/or effects on ND. In survey studies, human milk is preferable because it is a non-invasive matrix. Breast milk concentration of NT substances is the best non-invasive matrix to assess infant current exposure that closely reflects the prenatal exposure environment.
The main carriers of neurochemical contaminants from maternal blood to
Neurodevelopmental outcomes
Environmental neurotoxic substances have multiple exposure media, and can occur simultaneously, but a difference in metabolism determines a complex correlation structure with the ND test outcome; thus, the end result may be additive, neutralizing or potentiated (synergistic effect) by the modeled stressors (or biomarkers). The studies listed in Table 3, Table 4, Table 5 used biomarkers of exposure/effect to the neurotoxic substance of interest (or metabolites) that were measured directly from
Concluding remarks
- – This review identified factors contributing to developmental delays in at least one of five categories: occupational, iatrogenic, biotoxins in aquatic food, environmental, psychosocial, and socioeconomic.
- – Pesticides and neurotoxic metals are part of the LAC environment that is transferred during pregnancy and lactation (including substitute pediatric formulas).
- – During critical stages of development (pregnancy and lactation) exposure to neurotoxicants are very complex to analyze fully (especially
Recommendations for public health authorities and professionals
1) Restrict/control exposure to neurotoxic substances, especially in women and children; 2) Provide educational tools to attenuate and/or to reduce developmental delays; 3) Develop products that do not harm the central nervous system of children; 4) Strengthen the neurological system intrinsically through breastfeeding and neuroprotective practices, and schooling that remediates cognitive deficits.
Declaration of competing interest
The author declares no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
References (232)
Developmental neurotoxicity of succeeding generations of insecticides
Environ. Int.
(2017)
et al.
Indices of mercury contamination during breast feeding in the Amazon Basin
Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol.
(1998)
et al.
Prenatal ?uoride exposure and attention defcit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD. symptoms in children at 6-12 years of age in Mexico City
Environ. Int.
(2018)
et al.
Exposure to an organochlorine pesticide (chlordecone) and development of 18 month-old infants
Neurotoxicology
(2013)
et al.
Exposure to arsenic and lead and neuropsychological development in Mexican children
Environ. Res.
(2001)
et al.
The impact of environmental metals in young urbanites’ brains
Exp. Toxicol. Pathol.
(2013)
et al.
Prefrontal white matter pathology in air pollution exposed Mexico City young urbanites and their potential impact on neurovascular unit dysfunction and the development of Alzheimer’s disease
Environ. Res.
(2016)
et al.
Hallmarks of Alzheimer disease are evolving relentlessly in Metropolitan Mexico City infants, children and young adults. APOE4 carriers have higher suicide risk and higher odds of reaching NFT stage V at ? 40 years of age
Environ. Res.
(2018)
et al.
The pediatric burden of disease from lead exposure at toxic waste sites in low and middle income countries
Environ. Res.
(2014)
et al.
Qualitative assessment of visuospatial errors in mercury-exposed Amazonian children
Neurotoxicology
(2009)
et al.
Uncovering neurodevelopmental windows of susceptibility to manganese exposure using dentine microspatial analyses
Environ. Res.
(2018)
et al.
Pyrethroids in human breast milk: occurrence and nursing daily intake estimation
Environ. Int.
(2012)
et al.
Neurodevelopmental investigations among methymercury-exposed children in French Guiana
Environ Res Section A
(2002)
et al.
Passive monitoring techniques to evaluate environmental pesticide exposure: results from the Infant’s Environmental Health study (ISA)
Environ. Res.
(2020)
et al.
Cognitive, visual, and motor development of 7-month-old Guadeloupean infants exposed to chlordecone
Environ. Res.
(2012)
et al.
Prenatal manganese exposure and intrinsic functional connectivity of emotional brain areas in children
Neurotoxicology
(2018)
et al.
A cross-sectional study of general cognitive abilities among Uruguayan school children with low-level arsenic exposure, potential effect modification by methylation capacity and dietary folate
Environ. Res.
(2018)
et al.
Executive functions in school children from Montevideo, Uruguay and their associations with concurrent low-level arsenic exposure
Environ. Int.
(2020)
et al.
Nutritional and immunological factors in breast milk: a role in the intergenerational transmission from maternal psychopathology to child development
Brain Behav. Immun.
(2020)
et al.
Bioavailability and pharmacokinetics of arsenic are influenced by the presence of cadmium
Chemosphere
(2014)
et al.
Neurodevelopmental performance among school age children in rural Guatemala is associated with prenatal and postnatal exposure to carbon monoxide, a marker for exposure to woodsmoke
Neurotoxicology
(2012)
et al.
Cassava cyanogens and fish mercury are high but safely consumed in the diet of native Amazonians
Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf.
(2004)
Multiple low-level exposures: Hg interactions with co-occurring neurotoxic substances in early life
Biochim. Biophys. Acta Gen. Subj.
(2019)
Environmental exposure to low-level lead (Pb) co-occurring with other neurotoxicants in early life and neurodevelopment of children
Environ. Res.
(2019)
Neurotoxic effects of joint exposures to aluminum and mercury in early life (infancy)
Environ. Res.
(2020)
Correlation between changeable human milk constituents and milk intake in breast-fed babies
J. Pediatr.
(1982)
et al.
Perinatal metabolism of dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene in Nicaraguan mothers
Environ. Res.
(2001)
et al.
Age related effects of pesticide exposure on neurobehavioral performance of adolescent farm workers in Brazil
Neurotoxicol. Teratol.
(2007)
et al.
Urinary 3,5,6-trichloro-2-pyridinol (TCPY) in pregnant women from Mexico City: distribution, temporal variability, and relationship with child attention and hyperactivity
Int. J. Hyg Environ. Health
(2014)
et al.
Latent subgroups of cognitive performance in lead- and manganese-exposed Uruguayan children: examining behavioral signatures
Neurotoxicology (Little Rock)
(2019)
et al.
Thimerosal: clinical, epidemiologic and biochemical studies
Clin. Chim. Acta
(2015)
et al.
Prenatal exposure to environmental pollutants and child development trajectories through 7 years
Int. J. Hyg Environ. Health
(2018)
et al.
Environmental toxicology: sensitive periods of development and neurodevelopmental disorders
Neurotoxicology
(2017)
et al.
Dentine biomarkers of prenatal and early childhood exposure to manganese, zinc and lead and childhood behavior
Environ. Int.
(2018)
et al.
Using the delayed spatial alternation task to assess environmentally associated changes in working memory in very young children
Neurotoxicology
(2020)
et al.
Overview of human health and chemical mixtures: problems facing developing countries
Environ. Health Perspect.
(2002)
et al.
No evidence of developmental III effects of low-level lead exposure in a developing country
J. Dev. Behav. Pediatr.
(1994)
et al.-
Minor and Trace Elements in Human Milk. Report of a Joint WHO/IAEA Collaborative Study
(1989)
Economic gradients in early child neurodevelopment: a multi-country study
Soc. Sci. Med.
(2013)
et al.
Living on higher ground reduces child neurodevelopment-evidence from South America
J. Pediatr.
(2013)
Urinary 3-phenoxybenzoic acid (3-PBA) levels among pregnant women in Mexico City: distribution and relationships with child neurodevelopment
Environ. Res.
(2016)
et al.
Genome-wide gene by lead exposure interaction analysis identifies UNC5D as a candidate gene for neurodevelopment
Environ. Health
(2017)
et al.
Breast milk excretion Kinetic of ?-HCH, pp’ DDE and pp’ DDT
Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.
(2009)
et al.
Persistent organochlorine pesticide levels in maternal blood serum, colostrum, and mature milk
Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.
(2002)
et al.
Organochlorine pesticide levels in maternal adipose tissue, maternal blood serum, umbilical blood serum, and milk from inhabitants of Veracruz, Mexico
Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.
(2001)
et al.
Comparison of organochlorine pesticide levels in adipose tissue and human milk of mothers living in Veracruz, Mexico
Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.
(1999)
et al.
Organochlorine pesticide residues in human breast milk from tropical areas in Mexico
Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.
(1996)
et al.
Total and methyl-mercury in hair and milk of mothers living in the city of Porto Velho and in villages along the Rio Madeira, Amazon, Brazil
Int. J. Hyg Environ. Health
(2013)
et al.
[Chronic exposure to environmental lead in Chilean infants. II: effects on the psychomotor development]
Rev. Med. Chile
(1999)
et al.
Prenatal molybdenum exposure and infant neurodevelopment in Mexican children
Nutr. Neurosci.
(2014)
et al.